document #295
DRMAA2 - GFD-R-P.194 - Errata 2
| Status: | published | Start date: | 08/03/2015 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | Normal | Due date: | ||
| Assignee: | Greg Newby | % Done: | 0% |
|
| Category: | - | |||
| Target version: | - | |||
| Document Type: | Proposed Recommendation |
Description
The DRMAA Version 2 root specification was published in January 2012 as GFD-R-P.194. In September 2012, a first errata was published for the root specification.
DRMAA2 is now fully adopted in Univa GridEngine. This industry-grade implementation showed some issues with the C binding, which partly also influence the root specification. Furthermore, a large set of clarifications needed to be done in the document text. Another reason for changes were the ongoing Python and OCCI binding developments.
Given the necessary changes, we created the attached updated version of the root spec.
Please check the annex chapter of the attached file for a list of changes. We leave it to the GFSG if these changes demand a new GFD number, or if they can be treated as another errata publication.
History
Updated by Greg Newby about 7 years ago
- Status changed from submitted to initial review
- Assignee set to Greg Newby
Thanks for this submission. Based on the extent of changes, I believe it is most appropriate to proceed with a new GFD # that will obsolete the older one. I will bring this to the Standards Council for confirmation of this, and to proceed with the next steps towards public comment and eventual publication. It's great to see that this has been adopted by industry, and that real-world experiences have helped to inform the changes. Greg
Updated by Greg Newby almost 7 years ago
Dear authors/editors: apologies for the delay with this. I am re-raising my suggestion with the standards council.
- Greg
Updated by Greg Newby almost 7 years ago
- Assignee changed from Greg Newby to Wolfgang Ziegler
Per the Standards Council telecon December 8, we will proceed with a new GFD #, obsoleting the older versions. The AD will check that these submissions are ready for public comment.
- Greg
Updated by Greg Newby almost 7 years ago
- Status changed from initial review to AD review
Updated by Wolfgang Ziegler almost 7 years ago
I checked the document and it is almost ready for the public phase.
Things to do:
- The document needs a new GFD number that should be sent to the authors to replace the current 194
- The authors should update the date of the copyright statements on page 1 and 59
- The should update the "Obsoletes" paragraph: This document obsoletes GFD-R-P.194 (and probably add a reference to
GFD-R-P.194
Updated by Wolfgang Ziegler almost 7 years ago
- Assignee changed from Wolfgang Ziegler to Greg Newby
Can you please send me the new GFD number for this document
Updated by Greg Newby almost 7 years ago
- Status changed from AD review to author action
- Assignee changed from Greg Newby to Wolfgang Ziegler
Dear Wolfgang,
The doc # should be marked as "TBD" or similar, for now. This has not yet gone to public comment, so usually we wait until the document is closer to final publication to assign a new number.
The other changes mentioned in the tracker are similarly minor. This should be ready for public comment, as soon as any immediately forthcoming changes are made. Let me know, and we will put it in a public comment tracker, and announce it.
Thanks,
Greg
Updated by Peter Tröger over 6 years ago
- File drmaav2.pdf added
As requested, here is an updated version of the PDF file that is suitable for another public comment phase.
Updated by Jens Jensen over 6 years ago
- Status changed from author action to initial review
- Assignee changed from Wolfgang Ziegler to Andre Merzky
Public comments
Updated by Redmine Admin over 6 years ago
The public comment tracker is now available at https://redmine.ogf.org/projects/editor-pubcom/boards/36
Updated by Greg Newby over 6 years ago
Andre, please extend the public comment date to August 31. I will then announce.
Updated by Greg Newby over 6 years ago
- Status changed from initial review to public comment
Updated by Greg Newby about 6 years ago
- Status changed from public comment to AD review
- Assignee changed from Andre Merzky to Wolfgang Ziegler
Public comment is complete, and no comments were received. We will seek input on next steps from the standards council and area director.
The PC tracker: https://redmine.ogf.org/projects/editor-pubcom/boards/36
Updated by Greg Newby about 6 years ago
Prior to publication, Wolfgang will check with the group in case there are other errata that should be considered. This is due to the long delay between submission and publication.
Updated by Wolfgang Ziegler about 6 years ago
- Assignee changed from Wolfgang Ziegler to Greg Newby
The group considers the documents ready for publication, no further changes needed.
Updated by Greg Newby about 6 years ago
- Status changed from AD review to to be published
Updated by Greg Newby about 6 years ago
- Status changed from to be published to author action
Peter, others: Please generate the final version as PDF, with the GFD #231. Once that is uploaded, along with the document source (.tgz or similar), I will put this in the published documents area at www.ogf.org and announce publicly. Thanks... Greg
Updated by Peter Tröger almost 6 years ago
- File drmaav2.pdf added
Please find attached the final document, as requested.
Updated by Greg Newby almost 6 years ago
- Status changed from author action to published
Published! Apologies for the delay. I left the date as November 21 at ogf.org, since these languished before I uploaded and announced them. Thanks to authors/editors for your work on these important updates to the DRMAA series.
(Other formats not available in this archive.