INFOD Current Actions ===================== This is a list of current actions. Each action has a serial number, once it is closed it is moved to a companion document of closed actions. ============================================================================== Actions with target date of <= 31 Jul 2005 9 Arjun 10 Steve F 13 Cecile 20 Vijay 21 Susan 24 Cecile 26 Abdeslem Actions with no date 17, 30 and 34 ============================================================================== 1 Add reference to appropriate appendix, or description for vocabulary, identity management, etc. in Page 5, para 2: we need references or brief explanation of vocabulary, identity management and principal as they all have a meaning which is peculiar to their context. - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Dieter - target date: 31 Jul 2005 2 Add Arjun to list of writers of specs... - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Cecile - Target date: 4 Aug 2005 3 After much discussion about using WSDM to stop/start our services, we decide that we agree that starting/stopping our service is out of scope - so add to non-goals of INFOD. - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Dieter - Target date: 4 Aug 2005 4 Figure 1 is confusing. Steve to come up with better diagram. http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/05/msg00003.html - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Steve - target date: 1 Aug 2005 5 Go over list of questions, clarifications addressed for chapter 1 in http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/05/msg00001.html (ch 2 questions have an open item for them) Page 4, para 4: "a publication specifies..." the first part is fine but then you say it "makes available". I don't think a publication should *do* anything. - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Dieter - Target date: 4 Aug 2005 6 Go over list of questions, clarifications addressed for chapter 2 in http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/05/msg00001.html (ch 1 questions have an open item for them) - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Dieter - Target 4 Aug 2005 8 Map the original infod registry object components back to operation parms newly defined to ensure no loss of function from Chicago June 05 F2f discussion - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Dieter, Cecile - target date: 31 Jul 2005 9 Update SensorNet scenario with operations as per Chicago F2F June 05 Include scenario to determine when consumer, consumption needed and decide whether definition of equivalent of association for consumption is needed - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Arjun - Target date: 31 Jul 2005 10 Update RGMA scenario with operations as per Chicago F2F June 05 - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Steve F - Target date: 31 Jul 2005 12 Write bank balance notification use case - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Dieter - Target date: 31 Aug 2005 13 Write e-mail filter use case - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Cecile - Target date: 31 Jul 2005 20 Ensure that existing glossary includes the following terms, and that they are defined in specs. - From http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2005/01/msg00006.html - Terms for INFOD to clarify, define: - Publisher, Consumer, Subscriber, Broker , Propagator (INFOD has no producer) - Continuous query Pushing, Polling and Pull Action Event – correlation of content and creation Type System Language Registry History and latest queries Mediation Primary and Secondary producers Topics Profiles Demand Driven Publishing Targeted Publishing Definition On Demand Publishing Definition On Demand Propagation Definition - vocabulary, identity, The event taxonomoy should be explained in the glossary - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Vijay - target date: 28 Jul 2005 21 Update the charter, to reflect new schedule - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owners: Susan - target date: 28 Jul 2005 22 Produce a plan for at least two implementations - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: - target date: GGF15 23 Provide response to document proposed by Vijay on infod suggested service modifications: - publication regenerate - some services can regenerate some cannot and need to cache - aspects of analyst role - lifetime management - and new point - Clarification: A publication can be viewed as a reaction to a query however the format of the published material may need to be considered or specified separately See https://forge.gridforum.org/projects/infod-wg/document/Info-D_Suggested_Service_Modifications/ for Vijay paper and see http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/07/msg00001.html for issue description - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Cecile - Target date: 4 Aug 2005 24 Document in specs summary of issues raised in Vijay's original append - and resolutions - and validate still accurate with existing infod specs: - declarative vs descriptive interfaces - type of data/temporal/meta events defined in infod - consumption See http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/08/msg00004.html and summarize resolutions as per: - http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/08/msg00005.html http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/08/msg00006.html http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/08/msg00007.html - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Cecile - Target date: 31 Jul 2005 25 Define relationship between Infod AND DAIS - document current positioning - resolve lifetime issues of INFOD objects vs DAIS sessions - 3rd party delivery support - This should probably go into a use case - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owners: Susan - target date: 31 Aug 2005 26 We will need to update spec to use WS-RF resource properties and operators. But our query semantics might be different than those of WSRF; so we'll have to be careful about how we structure the registry to allow it. - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owners: Abdeslem - target date: 28 Jul 2005 28 Produce interaction diagram to guide readers in understanding general usage - Date: 21 Jul 2005 - Owner: Chris - target date: need spec/api to settle 29 Write up consumer service requirement - is this addressed by POBOX? - Date: 21 Jul 2005 - Owner: Steve F. - Target date: Sep 4 2005 31 Define late binding and determine where late binding is supported Expanding recipient list from logical EPR? - Date: 21 Jul 2005 - Owner: Shailendra - Target date: 11 Aug 2005 32 Define non-events - are they deadline related? - Date: 21 Jul 2005 - Owner: Cecile and Dieter - Target date: 4 Aug 2005 33 Review what's in the specification on vocabularies and give feedback Which version - when should this be done? Now - Date: 21 Jul 2005 - Owner: Steve F - Target date:11 Aug 2005 34 Review what's in the specification about disseminators and give feedback. See issues 13 and 17 Which version - when should this be done? Not yet. - Date: 21 Jul 2005 - Owner: Abdeslem and Susan - Target date: 35 Break the spec into multiple logical documents defining different levels of INFOD OGSA profiles mandate base WSN. To be compliant we need to refactor around base notifications now and provide INFOD services as an extension to WS-BaseNotify?    http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/08/msg00010.html http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/infod-wg/2004/12/msg00000.html Questions to address include: How does WS-Eventing fit in? What's the difference between a disseminator and a WSN broker? publication and WSN topic? Vocabulary and WSN filter? Can WSN send message directly to a consumer by name? Publications are defined by topics in WSN, how does that differ from INFOD mechanisms for controlling publications through vocabularies? One proposal was to split: o Information Dissemination from publishers to consumers, allowing subscribers to subscribe on behalf of 3rd party consumers o Information Dissemination with one or more disseminators, but without propagation requirements between disseminators (disseminators do not talk to each other yet provide decoupling of publishers/subscribers/consumers interaction) o Information Dissemination with one or more disseminators and with possible propagation between disseminators (delivery of the "intelligent cloud" Another proposal from F2F was to look at the list of Requirements, and pick a few that are doable short term, and use it to drive the factoring from simple to more complex scenarios - and use that work to see how the 2 relate to each other (ie common short term items from both) - Date: 1 Jul 2005 - Owner: Cecile, Susan, Abdeslem - Target date: 4 Aug 2005