Notes from the GGF15 BOF on Data Transfer. Task: copying file hierarchy from A to B. - something has to check that sufficient space exists - do all source files exist? - what if the file hierarchy is a DAG? Need separate interface for file system operations. Copy semantics. - At least once. - Possibly at most once? - Copy to at least n sites from a list >= n. - Specifying number of retries or alternatively time by which transfer should complete Clean up on error? Transfer control - extensible for different protocols - limit bandwidth use Naming - abstract names or addresses? CERN resolves abstract names to replicas as part of this service.