Minutes Seventeenth OGSI-WG Teleconference February 3, 2003 @ 16:30 - 18:00 GMT Attendees: Karl Czajkowski, ISI Shel Finkelstein, Sun Steve Graham, IBM Dave Snelling, Fujitsu Steve Tuecke, ANL Pete Vanderbilt, NASA Andera Westerinen, Cisco 1) Approve minutes January 29th Teleconference - OK 2) Actions Review Action: Tom M. provide XML Schema and WSDL for the specification. Use gwsdl for WSDL 1.2 extensions (#35) - Pending Action: Andrew G. to write a document describing the options for reslover behavior (#17) - Pending Action: Steve Graham to craft language for recommendations to developers for use of resolvers (#17) - Pending Action: Steve T. and Steve G. to make sure that the WSDL group is aware of the OGSI's use of the WSDL 1.2 draft to be tied into the gwsdl draft - Pending Action: Steve G. to clarify the spec to make the differences between declaration, value, and element, e.g. clarify the conceptual model of Service Data types etc. - Done Action: Dave S to redraft fault words to reflect resolutions at January F2F and put Faults back on the agenda. - Pending New Actions: Action: Steve T to push Thomas Sandhome and Tom Maguire aim to have something out by Thursday. Resolved: Namespace names: gwsdl - for temporary stuff WSDL 1.2, but change gsdl to osgi Action: Steve T to change Namespace names as above. 3) Action list from Steve G's pass through the spec: Section 5 (GWSDL) Write it Action: Steve G: To drive draft by Wed Feb 5. Section 7.2 (I# 55) reconcile timestamp with OASIS WS-Security (Section 10) Addendum Action: Shel F to provide feedback by Wed Feb 5 with an eye to punting to V1.1 Section 7.3.1 (I# 90) delete wsdl:location We may need a broader solution, e.g. something like a registry, in V1.1 or driven by OGSA-WG. See ebxml registry, corba regitry, ... Resolved: Delete wsdl:location. Section 7.7 common handling of faults (re write this section per LA F2F) Action: Dave S by 7.7 by Wednesday Feb 5. Complete the faults for all operations in all portTypes Action: Pending until Wed 5 Section 9 (I#67) optional parms on operations Already resolved to use the EmptyExtensibility, Action: pending draft schema from Thomas and Tom. Section 9 (I#91) Factory Handle SDD nillability Resolved: If a 0, 1 case exists in the OGSI spec, we use nillability and specify specific semantics. See Factory case and Service Group case. Sections 9.2.1.2 and 9.2.1.3 convert to descriptive text, describing future direction Resolved: Remove explicit reference to Xpath, Query. Resolved: 6.2.1 to include parenthetical reference to (XPath, Xquery) Action: Steve G to create non-normative text for the service data section describing forward looking Section 9.2.3 SetByXUpdate (clarify text) Resolved: as above with 9.2.1.2/3. Section 9.2.2.2 (I#92) Syntax quibble with deletebySDName and deleteByMultSDName Resolved: Adopt 9.2.2.2 syntax (name list in attribute) and use the same style elsewhere in the spec, e.g. findServiceDataByName. Resolved: Use queryByMultipleServiceDataNames consistently, and make sure the singleton reference isn't there. Section 10 (I#17) Finish the handle resolver protocol discussion Action: See above. Section 12.1 Factory PortType SDD (I#93) and (I#94) Punt --- Sorry folks, that what my notes said. I must have drifted away. --- Anyway, we will come back to it, plus Steve's action below. Action: Steve T to check headings of service data. Section 12.2.1 Factory CreateService (I#19) Action: Steve T to check as this bug has been resolved already. May just need to remove highlighting. Section 13 Registration/ServiceGroup (Rewrite per LA F2F). Discussion on Wed Feb 5. 4) "The Pen" is with Steve T. to 1) Accept changes & 2) Tag problems he finds. 5) Issues from the Agenda to carry forward: *) Service data redirection. See Karl Czajkowski's mail -> Thu Dec 12, 2002: [ogsi-wg] find service data "links" in service data values? *) Resolver language *) Set Service Data Review 6) Open Bugzilla list: Bugs with actions assigned. Bug 17 - Recommend client use of HandleResolver over direct resolver protocols Bug 82 - New grid service instance registration to handle resolver Steve G. and Andrew G. Bug 35 - normative XML schema is needed Tom M. Bug 42 - The distinction between 'void return' and 'no return' in some operations Dave S. - Faults summary action. Bug 50 - RegisterService Fault for Registry portType Bug 63 - Replace WSIL (temporarily?) with a simple contents description. Bug 68 - The a Registration a bag or set and what is the key? Bug 69 - Timeout should be added back into the register operation in the Registration protType. Dave S. - Registration portType action. Notification Bugs: Bug 43 - The specialization of the DeliverNotification operation Bug 61 - Provide notification of destuction in the GSS Bug 66 - Allow modification of NotificationSubscriptions Bug ?? - Deliver with ack issue?? Bug ?? - Review Notification status and language (was an agenda item). WSDL Bugs: Bug 62 - Do we need a way to mark operations in a portType optional? Factory Bugs: Bug 72 - mutability of gsdl:CreatesPortTypes and CreationInputTypes Bug 73 - Factory::CreateService requester as SDE? Bug 74 - strictness of gsdl:CreatesPortTypes commentary Misc Bugs: Bug 70 - Change SDE names from "...Types" to "...Elements" Bug 39 - message identifier for audit Bug 77 - serviceDataNames minOccurs should be 7 Bug 30 - Define queryByXPath Bug 31 - Define queryByXQuery Bug 44 - Language linking notification subscriptions to SDEs. Bug 71 - CPU port-type example SDE inconsistent Bug 81 - GSS and WS-SD need unification. 7) Next meeting Wednesday Feb 5, 2003: Time: 08:30-10:00 US Pacific 09:30-11:00 US Mountain 10:30-12:00 US Central 11:30-13:00 US Eastern 15:30-17:00 GMT 16:30-18:00 UK 17:30-19:00 Central Europe 00:30-02:00 Japan Place: 484-630-8733 passcode 89914